Am I Mainly the Product of My Background? // Ask Pastor John

Share this & earn $10
Desiring God
Published at : 23 Oct 2020
8926 views
256
7

Are we free to be who we want to be, or are we instead the products of our backgrounds and environments?

Each of our lives is shaped by multiple forces — the friends we choose, the parents we didn’t choose, and the socioeconomic class background that we had little or no control over. So can we say we are mainly the product of our background? It’s a question to us from an anonymous young man, a college student.

“Hello, Pastor John! I’m majoring in psychology right now. One of my professors is a ‘radical behaviorist,’ and I have recently taken a course in learning and behavior. In this course, my instructor teaches that, according to B.F. Skinner’s ideas, man is basically a product of his environment and his reinforcements. In other words, Skinner argued that we are mechanical and do not have free will because we only act according to our reinforcements. Is there objective information that refutes Skinner’s ideas from a biblical perspective? And is there evidence outside of the Bible that suggests we do have free will?”

Read or listen to this interview at our website: https://www.desiringgod.org/interviews/am-i-mainly-the-product-of-my-background

Find other recent and popular Ask Pastor John episodes: https://www.desiringgod.org/ask-pastor-john
Desiring GodJohn PiperAsk Pastor John

Major Lazer - Particula (Karaoke) | CantoYo

Major Lazer - Particula (Karaoke) | CantoYo

Because of You 2020 - EP3 | Jealous Jerom Huang Alouf

Because of You 2020 - EP3 | Jealous Jerom Huang Alouf

Making $87,395 In 30 Mins Trading Stock Options

Making $87,395 In 30 Mins Trading Stock Options

Ark survival evolved - The Center! (Обзор карты Центр!)

Ark survival evolved - The Center! (Обзор карты Центр!)

Happily Never After | New York Post Reports: Off the Record

Happily Never After | New York Post Reports: Off the Record

[Touhou Vocal] [RD-Sounds] somewhat trustworthy (spanish & english subtitles)

[Touhou Vocal] [RD-Sounds] somewhat trustworthy (spanish & english subtitles)

A leghasznosabb online marketing tanács 2019-re

A leghasznosabb online marketing tanács 2019-re

Becoming aware of Awareness. Realizing ourselves as Awareness.

Becoming aware of Awareness. Realizing ourselves as Awareness.

[MV] 10cm _ Phonecert (폰서트)

[MV] 10cm _ Phonecert (폰서트)

Case Study Felthouse Vs Bindley

Case Study Felthouse Vs Bindley

Best Learning Video for Toddlers Learn Colors with Crayon Surprises!

Best Learning Video for Toddlers Learn Colors with Crayon Surprises!

DAWN (던) - ‘MONEY’ MV

DAWN (던) - ‘MONEY’ MV

Дорога до 10 уровня фейсит. Играем со зрителями. Розыгрыши. Стрим CSGO

Дорога до 10 уровня фейсит. Играем со зрителями. Розыгрыши. Стрим CSGO

Interview With Kamal Patel of Examine.com | Red Meat, Aspartame, & Omega 3's

Interview With Kamal Patel of Examine.com | Red Meat, Aspartame, & Omega 3's

Hello 2019 x46

Hello 2019 x46

Have a look at this big fella.

Have a look at this big fella.

The ENDGAME Is Here - Mike Maloney & George Gammon (Part 2)

The ENDGAME Is Here - Mike Maloney & George Gammon (Part 2)

8-bit super comes in handy

8-bit super comes in handy

ASMR super ZOOM Removing ingrown hair on face.

ASMR super ZOOM Removing ingrown hair on face.

Nas - You Wouldn't Understand ft. Victoria Monet

Nas - You Wouldn't Understand ft. Victoria Monet

Some Things Never Change (From "Frozen 2"/Sing-Along)

Some Things Never Change (From "Frozen 2"/Sing-Along)

The Will

The Will

GRAMMAR: Como usar RATHER THAN!!! | Prof. Newton Rocha #dicadeinglês

GRAMMAR: Como usar RATHER THAN!!! | Prof. Newton Rocha #dicadeinglês

Angels Choir Singing: THE TABERNACLE, THE DWELLING PLACE OF GOD [7 HOURS]

Angels Choir Singing: THE TABERNACLE, THE DWELLING PLACE OF GOD [7 HOURS]

MOO-Markiplier (clean)

MOO-Markiplier (clean)

Giving Feedback - 3 Funny Examples of Giving Employee Feedback

Giving Feedback - 3 Funny Examples of Giving Employee Feedback

模拟入籍面试彩排3.这段彩排是面试的一部分,包括现用名,曾用名,更名的说法以及验证入籍资格.

模拟入籍面试彩排3.这段彩排是面试的一部分,包括现用名,曾用名,更名的说法以及验证入籍资格.

BLACKPINK - REALLY / SEE U LATER - Wembley Arena, London - 22/5/2019

BLACKPINK - REALLY / SEE U LATER - Wembley Arena, London - 22/5/2019

Emergency Life Hacks with Superhero | Useful Hacks & Tips That May Save You In Emergency Situations

Emergency Life Hacks with Superhero | Useful Hacks & Tips That May Save You In Emergency Situations

‘No Talk Of A Concession’ By Trump Campaign Amid Latest Vote Counts | TODAY

‘No Talk Of A Concession’ By Trump Campaign Amid Latest Vote Counts | TODAY

We Discovered a Hidden Gem in Tirthan Valley - Village Laida

We Discovered a Hidden Gem in Tirthan Valley - Village Laida

How To ALWAYS WIN In AMONG US! (Insane)

How To ALWAYS WIN In AMONG US! (Insane)

7 Second Demo: Easy Accessibility

7 Second Demo: Easy Accessibility

Camerata Nordica String Orchestra - Grieg "Holberg Suite"

Camerata Nordica String Orchestra - Grieg "Holberg Suite"

Spitfire in first light

Spitfire in first light

P!NK - So What (iHeartRadio Music Festival) - Amazing performance!

P!NK - So What (iHeartRadio Music Festival) - Amazing performance!

BTS (방탄소년단) 'FAKE LOVE' Official MV

BTS (방탄소년단) 'FAKE LOVE' Official MV

Price Of Creativity - let's discuss with Meriem Messaadia

Price Of Creativity - let's discuss with Meriem Messaadia

All the countries portrayed by Minecraft

All the countries portrayed by Minecraft

My Head is Filled With Music

My Head is Filled With Music

Upper Body Toning // No Repeats Workout

Upper Body Toning // No Repeats Workout

The Unlucky Inn

The Unlucky Inn

Freaky Eating: Help! I'm Addicted To Bricks!

Freaky Eating: Help! I'm Addicted To Bricks!

Māori ministers steer clear of Ihumātao conflict

Māori ministers steer clear of Ihumātao conflict

Talk & Challenge #2: Hậu vòng 3, GDucky, RTee vừa hội ngộ Hành Or đã va thử thách căng não| RAP VIỆT

Talk & Challenge #2: Hậu vòng 3, GDucky, RTee vừa hội ngộ Hành Or đã va thử thách căng não| RAP VIỆT

Tasha Cobbs Leonard - "For Your Glory"

Tasha Cobbs Leonard - "For Your Glory"

DAVID GOGGINS, DORIAN YATES & ROSS EDGLEY - WHY MOST PEOPLE QUIT AT 40% | LONDON REAL JOURNEYS

DAVID GOGGINS, DORIAN YATES & ROSS EDGLEY - WHY MOST PEOPLE QUIT AT 40% | LONDON REAL JOURNEYS

Lukasz Wenta Wins the 2019 Caber Toss, a breakdown

Lukasz Wenta Wins the 2019 Caber Toss, a breakdown

Photoshop CC 10: The Big BIG Selection Tutorial, Part 1 - the Basics

Photoshop CC 10: The Big BIG Selection Tutorial, Part 1 - the Basics