Was World Series' Muncy-Adames Tag Play at 2B the New Gant-Hrbek?

Share this & earn $10
CloseCallSports
Published at : 25 Oct 2020
3190 views
48
6

Dodgers batter-runner Max Muncy slid into second base in Game 4 of the 2020 World Series, colliding with Rays SS Willy Adames and ultimately resulting in an out call from 2B Umpire Mark Carlson...but was it correct?

The question at hand is whether or not Adames forced Muncy off of the base illegally: What is the actual rule? According to baseball's official interpretation, if a runner is pushed or forced off a base by a fielder at which the runner would have otherwise been called safe, the umpire has the authority and discretion to award the runner the base.

But the phrase "would have otherwise been called safe" is a deep well: This video discussion how an umpire determines whether this criterion has been satisfied, relative to a runner's demonstration of body control (or lack thereof), excess momentum, fielder's actions, and totality of the play.

Finally, we compare and contrast Muncy-Adames with Gant-Hrbek (including audio from Drew Coble, who was the umpire for the Gant-Hrbek play in Minnesota) to determine whether Muncy should have been deemed safe or whether Carlson's out call was proper.
WorldSeries'Muncy-Adames

10 Free to Play MMORPGs You Should Try In May, 2020!

10 Free to Play MMORPGs You Should Try In May, 2020!

What can give to a 09-12 months Baby for Breakfast?

What can give to a 09-12 months Baby for Breakfast?

Top 10 Stories of Unusual People  | Thank You For Subscribing. You Are The Best!!!

Top 10 Stories of Unusual People | Thank You For Subscribing. You Are The Best!!!

BELLAMI HAIR EXTENSIONS HONEST REVIEW/ COMPARISON TO LUXY

BELLAMI HAIR EXTENSIONS HONEST REVIEW/ COMPARISON TO LUXY

All I ever wanted , all I ever needed, is here..in my arms!

All I ever wanted , all I ever needed, is here..in my arms!

A Moment of Accomplishment

A Moment of Accomplishment

17+ COOLEST GADGETS FOR BOYS Under Rs500 to 1000 & More Rupees You Can Buy Online

17+ COOLEST GADGETS FOR BOYS Under Rs500 to 1000 & More Rupees You Can Buy Online

The Grouch - Rap Is Senseless

The Grouch - Rap Is Senseless

PRAYER POINTS AGAINST EVIL DOERS | PRAYER AGAINST EVIL DOERS | PRAYER FOR PROTECTION FROM EVIL DOERS

PRAYER POINTS AGAINST EVIL DOERS | PRAYER AGAINST EVIL DOERS | PRAYER FOR PROTECTION FROM EVIL DOERS

Using 'can', 'could', 'be able to' and 'manage to' - 6 Minute Grammar

Using 'can', 'could', 'be able to' and 'manage to' - 6 Minute Grammar

10 things I learned after losing a lot of money | Dorothée Loorbach | TEDxMünster

10 things I learned after losing a lot of money | Dorothée Loorbach | TEDxMünster

FUNNY DOGS, prepare yourself to CRY WITH LAUGHTER! - Best DOG VIDEOS

FUNNY DOGS, prepare yourself to CRY WITH LAUGHTER! - Best DOG VIDEOS

outdoors - tired

outdoors - tired

Grace VanderWaal - So Much More Than This (Lyrics)

Grace VanderWaal - So Much More Than This (Lyrics)

Stop Motion Cooking - INSECTS BBQ PARTY From Centipedes and MealWorms ASMR

Stop Motion Cooking - INSECTS BBQ PARTY From Centipedes and MealWorms ASMR

It May be The Water

It May be The Water

Patients With Dementia Benefit from Playlist for Life

Patients With Dementia Benefit from Playlist for Life

ONE DIP Makeup Challenge! HELP!

ONE DIP Makeup Challenge! HELP!

This guy looks Egyptian...

This guy looks Egyptian...

НАУЧИТЬСЯ СТАНТИТЬ ЗА ПАРУ ЧАСОВ, РЕАЛЬНО?

НАУЧИТЬСЯ СТАНТИТЬ ЗА ПАРУ ЧАСОВ, РЕАЛЬНО?

Why Mason Mount is ESSENTIAL To Frank Lampard's Chelsea! w/ Alex Goldberg

Why Mason Mount is ESSENTIAL To Frank Lampard's Chelsea! w/ Alex Goldberg

FREE FIRE BOT CHALLENGE IN CLASH SQUAD OVERPOWER GAMEPLAY - GARENA FREE FIRE

FREE FIRE BOT CHALLENGE IN CLASH SQUAD OVERPOWER GAMEPLAY - GARENA FREE FIRE

NEVER Do This When Cutting Down A Tree!!

NEVER Do This When Cutting Down A Tree!!

The Struggle

The Struggle

BLACKPINK's Biggest BOMBSHELLS From 'Light Up The Sky' Documentary!

BLACKPINK's Biggest BOMBSHELLS From 'Light Up The Sky' Documentary!

This is hard to admit. | reaction to Abbey Sharp

This is hard to admit. | reaction to Abbey Sharp

橫跨陰陽服務神鬼的潮流道長!誰說信仰又老又舊只是拿香跟拜?!即便被瞧不起,他也立志讓道教潮流化!《百工職魂第五十五集-潮流道長 The Belief in Craft-No.55 》

橫跨陰陽服務神鬼的潮流道長!誰說信仰又老又舊只是拿香跟拜?!即便被瞧不起,他也立志讓道教潮流化!《百工職魂第五十五集-潮流道長 The Belief in Craft-No.55 》

EN | Bosch Multi-camera system – All-around vision when parking and maneuvering

EN | Bosch Multi-camera system – All-around vision when parking and maneuvering

Hammerers - Gianny For Example

Hammerers - Gianny For Example

Medicine - Queen of tension

Medicine - Queen of tension

How the food you eat affects your brain - Mia Nacamulli

How the food you eat affects your brain - Mia Nacamulli

Alicia Keys - Fallin' (Live from Apple Music Festival, London, 2016)

Alicia Keys - Fallin' (Live from Apple Music Festival, London, 2016)

Roby J - Public Domain Age

Roby J - Public Domain Age

Glorious - Le fils prodigue

Glorious - Le fils prodigue

TOP 3 PENNY STOCKS To BUY NOW That Will Make You MONEY🔥🔥🔥

TOP 3 PENNY STOCKS To BUY NOW That Will Make You MONEY🔥🔥🔥

26 GENIUS HACKS TO SAVE YOUR MONEY

26 GENIUS HACKS TO SAVE YOUR MONEY

Block B - HER [2014 KBS Song Festival / 2015.01.14]

Block B - HER [2014 KBS Song Festival / 2015.01.14]

All For Us - Labrinth & Zendaya (lyrics)

All For Us - Labrinth & Zendaya (lyrics)

Bon Jovi - Livin' On A Prayer (Official Music Video)

Bon Jovi - Livin' On A Prayer (Official Music Video)

18 DIY NATURAL HOME REMEDIES

18 DIY NATURAL HOME REMEDIES

Incredible longest band saw blade manufacturing process. Amazing machines production process methods

Incredible longest band saw blade manufacturing process. Amazing machines production process methods

Most Practical Supercar? | Super Acceleration | Hyderabad India

Most Practical Supercar? | Super Acceleration | Hyderabad India

Genuinely Meaning

Genuinely Meaning

QOUNFUZED - DRINKS/GOODVIBES

QOUNFUZED - DRINKS/GOODVIBES

Past vs History

Past vs History

Nightcore - Unexpectedly - (Lyrics)

Nightcore - Unexpectedly - (Lyrics)

Thoroughly Modern Millie 15th Anniversary Reunion Concert Highlights

Thoroughly Modern Millie 15th Anniversary Reunion Concert Highlights

Crystal Radio Sets from 1920s & 1930s

Crystal Radio Sets from 1920s & 1930s

26.Prayer while Travelling

26.Prayer while Travelling